40 actions to celebrate ISHR’s 40th anniversary
We are celebrating longstanding and collective efforts in supporting human rights defenders. Join us and find out more!
Egypt | UN human rights experts denounce reprisal against lawyer Ebrahim Metwally
In respect of a clear case of reprisal, where an invitation from a UN body is being treated as evidence, UN experts highlight their deep concern about the detention and torture of an Egyptian human rights defender.
In an urgent joint statement on 15 September 2017, the Chair of the UN Working Group on enforced or involuntary disappearances (WGEID) and the Special Rapporteur on the situation of human rights defenders expressed dismay about the arrest of lawyer and activist, Ebrahim Abdelmonem Metwally Hegazy.
Metwally, the co-founder of the Association of the Families of the Disappeared – a network of families of forcibly disappeared in Egypt – was arrested and prevented from boarding a flight to Geneva on 10 September to attend the 113th Session of the WGEID. Metwally founded the Association of the Families of Disappeared following the disappearance of his son in July 2013, whose whereabouts remain unknown.
The WGEID and Special Rapporteur denounced the way he is treated, stating that ‘the fact that Mr. Metwally was arrested while en route to meet the Working Group suggests that this is an act of reprisal for his cooperation with a United Nations human rights mechanism, as well as a deliberate obstruction of his legitimate human rights activity to seek to establish the fate and whereabouts of his son and other disappeared people in Egypt.’
This case takes place in the context of increased reports of cases of intimidation and reprisal. Metwally’s whereabouts remained unknown for two days following his arrest. It has been alleged that he was tortured during that time. Since the arrest, he has been charged with ‘running a group that was illegally established, spreading false news, and cooperating with foreign organisations’. He was issued with a 15-day detention order and transferred to the Maximum Security Prison known as Scorpion (al-Aqrab) at the Tora Prisons Complex in Cairo, a prison notorious for inhumane detention conditions and the ill-treatment of prisoners.
The UN experts called on the Egyptian authorities to, ‘immediately provide us with all relevant information concerning his arrest and detention, to fully ensure Mr Metwally’s right to physical and psychological integrity as well as to due process.’ The experts expressed serious concern with regard to the allegations that Metwally had been tortured. Their statement has also been endorsed by the UN Working Group on arbitrary detention.
‘We are incredibly concerned by this undeniable case of reprisal. It is the clearest signal that more needs to be done by the Human Rights Council, its President and States to develop a systematic response to reprisals’, said ISHR’s Legal Counsel and reprisals focal point Tess McEvoy. ‘We call on States to support the resolution on reprisals currently being negotiated at the Human Rights Council. The right to communicate with the UN must be protected’, McEvoy added.
Contact: Tess McEvoy, Legal Counsel and reprisals focal point, [email protected].
Photo: Association of the Families of Disappeared, Egypt
Related articles
As expert presents report on gender apartheid to the UN, civil society calls for accountability
During an Enhanced Interactive Dialogue with the Special Rapporteur on Afghanistan on 19 June, in which he presented his most recent report to the UN Human Rights Council, ISHR made a statement noting that the pursuit of justice for women and girls in Afghanistan demands a multifaceted approach including various accountability mechanisms.
States must desist from and ensure accountability for transnational repression
Human rights defenders and journalists face increasing threats and attacks due to acts of transnational repression, according to a new report by the UN Special Rapporteur on Freedom of Expression. Host States must increase protection and support for victims of transnational repression, as well as investigate and pursue accountability where such acts occur.