During a side event, ISHR co-hosted on the margins of the 81st Ordinary Session of the African Commission, panellists reviewed the state of environmental defenders’ rights and reiterated their call for an African regional framework on environmental rights.
On 16 October 2024, ISHR co-hosted, as part of the Environmental Rights Agreement (ERA) Coalition, a side event on the margins of the 81st Ordinary Session of the African Commission on Human and Peoples’ Rights (African Commission) on advancing environmental rights in Africa. The initiative aims to advocate for the adoption of an instrument that further develops environmental rights by considering recent developments, issues and risks those who defend the environment and climate face. This event is a continuation of discussions that started in 2023 in Arusha during the Commission’s 77th Ordinary Session where participants agreed such an instrument would strengthen the legal protection of environmental rights in Africa.
Threats and challenges
Environmental rights defenders face several threats to their lives and safety on the continent. In his presentation, Brighton Aryampa explained how defenders advocating against the East African Crude and Oil Project, in Uganda, are arbitrarily arrested and detained and face politically-driven charges to discourage them from conducting their advocacy. The government and its allies have mounted Strategic Lawsuits Against Public Participation (SLAPP suits) which have increased fears among defenders and may in the long run perpetuate environmentally unfriendly policies and projects as defenders will fear to speak out. Individuals rarely have access to information related to these projects and are not meaningfully consulted whenever such projects are undertaken. The African Commission approached Uganda through a letter of appeal to get more clarity on the allegations defenders made on the ground.
This letter would not have been possible without the collaboration between non-governmental organisations and the Commission. That is why CSOs should continue documenting these violations and approach the Commission to seek meaningful solutionsProfessor Remy Lumbu Ngoy, Special Rapporteur on Human Rights Defenders and Focal Point on Reprisals
A normative Protocol as a response?
The promotion of an African regional framework could advance environmental protection in a way that is sustainable, contextualised and applicable to the African context.
The adoption of a regional framework promoting access to information, participation and justice - such as in the form of a normative protocol to the African Charter on environmental rights based on Article 66 - could strengthen regional commitment to environmental protection, human rights, and sustainable development, and entrench the implementation of the right to a healthy environment on the continentTrésor Makunya, Africa Legal and Advocacy Officer at ISHR.
It could also provide greater protection for EHRDs and improve corporate accountability for environmental violations. Five normative protocols have thus far developed areas in the Charter, which were inadequately, or not at all, incorporated, at the time of its drafting and adoption in 1981. The normative basis for adopting supplementary protocols to the Charter, and the African Union’s consistent practice to that effect, are a sign that environmental rights could be better advanced within the African human rights system similarly.
A study as a way forward
The African Commission is an important body that, based on its consistent practice, can initiate the process of drafting this Protocol. It can draw inspiration from the European and American regions. However, given the African Commission’s practice requires a study that precedes the development of such a framework, the ERA Coalition introduced a draft Resolution the Commission could adopt to swiftly conduct a study to consider developing further normative standards on the protection and promotion of environmental rights in Africa.
Women human rights defenders (WHRD) working on environment and climate justice from around the world gathered in Geneva to participate in the Women Human Rights Advocacy Week (WHRD-AW) between 16 and 21 September. Discover their experience below!
On the International Day of the World's Indigenous Peoples, we recognise and celebrate the important role that Indigenous defenders play in the promotion and protection of human rights, their communities, territories and the environment.
On 21 May 2024, ISHR delivered a statement highlighting issues related to the impacts of extractive industries on the defence of human rights and the environment.
