As expert presents report on gender apartheid to the UN, civil society calls for accountability
During an Enhanced Interactive Dialogue with the Special Rapporteur on Afghanistan on 19 June, in which he presented his most recent report to the UN Human Rights Council, ISHR made a statement noting that the pursuit of justice for women and girls in Afghanistan demands a multifaceted approach including various accountability mechanisms.
The statement began by thanking the Special Rapporteur for his commitment to engaging with Afghan civil society. It further welcomed the report’s intersectional analysis of the establishment and enforcement of an institutionalised system of discrimination and segregation against women and girls, and the impact on men and boys in resisting this system of gender oppression.
‘This report is particularly significant in that it clearly articulates that gender apartheid most fully encapsulates the institutionalised and ideological nature of the human rights abuses against women and girls’, said ISHR’s Tess McEvoy, ‘a call that has come from Afghan women human rights defenders inside and outside the country’, she added.
Critically, the statement highlighted that the pursuit of justice demands a multifaceted approach including various accountability mechanisms, including establishing a Human Rights Council-mandated mechanism to engage deeper into investigations and evidence collection to contribute towards accountability. With strategic coordination, this can exert heightened pressure on the Taliban.
The statement also welcomed references in the report to marginalised communities including ethnic, religious and linguistic minorities and the multiple and intersecting violations they suffer, along with references to violations because of one’s sexual orientation and gender identity.
Finally, in response to the expert squarely placing into view the responsibilities of international actors, the statement echoed an ongoing call on all States to ensure that any engagement with the Taliban should not normalise the regime as it continues to violate international human rights. It highlighted that an inclusive and stable Afghanistan requires justice and accountability.
Tess McEvoy leads ISHR’s work on women and LGBTI human rights defenders, ISHR’s legal protection work and Treaty Bodies, and co-leads ISHR’s legal team which engages in strategic litigation for the protection of human rights defenders.
An amendment tabled to the resolution on violence against women and girls, due for action at the Third Committee, seeks to allow States to implement the text according to their own laws, priorities and values. In a joint statement, civil society organisations warn it could set a precedent for qualifying any resolution States negotiate.
Afghan women human rights defenders campaigned for years for an independent mechanism to gather evidence of crimes committed against them. Now, a UN budget advisory committee has recommended cutting 7 of the 17 posts requested for the Mechanism in 2027. States should reject the cuts at the Fifth Committee.
ISHR welcomes the UN General Assembly Third Committee’s adoption of the resolution on extrajudicial, summary or arbitrary executions with its reference to sexual orientation and gender identity intact. But a margin of just five votes is a warning ahead of the plenary vote in December.