Latin America & Caribbean

Mexico | Genuine commitment urgently needed to protect environmental and human rights defenders

The 'Mayan Train', a touristic train cutting across numerous areas of rich environmental and cultural diversity in Eastern Mexico, may sound like a fancy development project. But what the shiny brochure doesn't display are the terrible consequences for the indigenous communities who call this area home, and for the environment. Six UN experts have addressed those in a letter to the Government, raising expectations of a meaningful commitment by Mexico, as a re-elected member of the Human Rights Council, to address human rights concerns and protect defenders.

Six UN experts have expressed grave concerns in a recent joint letter to the Mexican Government, made public this week, about the human rights and environmental consequences of major development project ‘Mayan Train’. In an important move, the letter was also sent to UN-Habitat, whose support to the ‘Mayan Train’ -alongside that of other UN agencies, including UNESCO and UNOPS- appears in strong contradiction with other positions taken by the UN, in particular the Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights. In 2019, the Office’s country office had already noted publicly the failure of the Government’s consultation processes with indigenous communities to meet international standards.

In order to comply with international standards and obligations, the experts underscore the need for any consultations with affected communities to be ‘conducted with the representative structures identified by those indigenous communities themselves’, and that they are based on the ‘necessary information, including results from environmental impact assessments’: those guarantees must be implemented before the project starts.

During a panel discussion on indigenous human rights defenders at the 45th session of the Human Rights Council in September, Mexico delivered a joint statement urging States to take specific measures to ‘create the conditions for the free determination of their development process and well-being’, and to observe the ‘obligations in relevant international instruments such as ILO’s Convention No. 169’, that enshrines the right to free, prior and informed consent.

‘It is very difficult to build trust around a project of that scale, where an adequate environmental impact assessment is missing, and information is kept partially secret given that sections of the railway have been entrusted to the Secretary of National Defense (SEDENA)’, said Raphaël Viana David, from the International Service for Human Rights (ISHR). ‘Transparency is instrinsical to a strong human rights-compliant approach, an absolute prerequisite for the project to move forward’.

In a joint statement released today, ISHR, together with CEMDA, CRIPX, CMDPDH, DPLF and PODER, urge the Mexican Government to swiftly respond to the experts’ concerns, and halt the ‘Mayan Train’ project until all human rights and other guarantees under ILO Convention 169 and relevant international treaties have been fully implemented.

‘There may be many obstacles to fulfilling its obligations, the first of which being the lack of political will’, said Viana. ‘we would like to hear from the Mexican Government why they are not talking to affected communities in the way they are required to’.

Translating international commitments into action on the ground

Of particular concern is that several organisations, including some among the signatories to the joint statement, were subject to repeated harassment and defamation, in a number of media outlets and in a declaration by Mexican President López-Obrador to the press on 28 August, blaming them for reportedly ‘receiving foreign funds to oppose the project’. These acts were publicly denounced by civil society organisations, including during the September session of the Human Rights Council.

Yet, the ‘Mayan Train’ case is not isolated, but rather emblematic of broader and alarming trend of attacks against human rights defenders overall, and women human rights defenders in particular. In June, chilling threats made by an organised crime group to Consorcio Oaxaca spurred Mary Lawlor, the Special Rapporteur on human rights defenders, to express public preoccupation about ‘intimidation, threats and killings targeting women human rights defenders’. No later than last week, a preventive press release by another group of experts, ahead of the 16 Days of Activism against Gender-Based Violence, stressed the need for ‘accountability for the way police officers treat women protesters and women human rights defenders, who play a crucial role in promoting women’s right to a life free from violence’, following police repression against feminist protests in Cancún.

It is against this background that the Mexican Senate, urged by the Executive, still voted to cut the funds of the National Protection Mechanism for Human Rights Defenders and Journalists last 21 October. ‘National protection mechanisms play a vital role in guaranteeing the safety of defenders, particularly in countries like Mexico’, said Viana. ‘But publicly recognising the essential role defenders play, and refraining from any type of intimidation or smear, are also powerful tools of ‘soft’ protection for them’.

Mexico has also taken some important steps in the right direction, markedly the ratification of the Escazú Agreement, allowing for the entry into force of this landmark regional treaty protecting environmental defenders and promoting environmental justice, participation, and transparency.

‘For them to be meaningful, it is crucial that Mexico’s international commitments be translated into genuine efforts to support and protect defenders at the national level’, stressed Viana. ‘This entails a number of key measures, including to promptly restore adequate funding to its national protection mechanism’.

In its bid for a seat in 2021 at the Human Rights Council, the UN’s top deliberative body for human rights, Mexico placed a feminist agenda high in its priorities, and pledged to strenghten protection of journalists and defenders, recognising their role in maintaining a ‘healthy democracy’. Mexico’s reelection to, and long-term membership at, the Human Rights Council represents both an opportunity it should embrace to implement such commitments, but also a heightened responsability not to leave those commitments -to support to civil society, or to advance women’s rights- only for the appreciation of international peers in Geneva and New York. In doing so, it should address the recommendations listed by a group of national and international rights groups prior to its reelection.

For more information, please contact Raphaël Viana David at [email protected], or on Twitter at @vdraphael.

Image credits: Flickr / Jesús Villaseca Pérez

Related articles

Elections | Human Rights Council Pledging Event 2021

This week in an online event, 10 candidate States publicly spoke to an audience of around 200 people on their pledges as incoming Human Rights Council members for 2022 – 2024. They also faced questions on pressing human rights issues from both States and civil society organisations.

Business & Human Rights | The UN asks private companies to protect the shared civic space

Should businesses advocate for human rights defenders? What is the relationship between companies’ economic activities and civil society? The United Nations, through the Working Group on Business and Human Rights, has shed further light on the role of businesses by recently releasing a guidance for companies on ensuring respect for human rights defenders.

NGO Forum | Implementation of the African Commission’s decision on the rights of the Endorois indigenous people of Kenya

To date, the African Commission on Human and Peoples’ Rights’ (the African Commission) recommendations to the Kenyan Government on reparations for the eviction of Endorois indigenous people from their ancestral lands in the 1970s remain largely unimplemented. On 13 April 2021, the NGO Forum met to discuss the status of the implementation of the African Commission’s 2010 decision 276/2003 on the rights of the Endorois people.

HRC47 | ISHR welcomes new UN Guidance on Business and Human Rights Defenders and calls for its implementation

In a statement at the Human Rights Council, ISHR welcomed the UN Working Group’s recently released Guidance document for using the Guiding Principles on Business and Human Rights for engaging with, safeguarding and ensuring respect for the rights of Human Rights Defenders. Human rights defenders are at the forefront of protecting their communities, the environment and key natural resources that maintain the balance in our planet.

Annual Report | Supporting humanity's essential workers

It's difficult to encapsulate such a complex year in a word, but "interconnected" is one that comes to mind when reflecting on 2020. We are proud to have remained deeply interconnected with defenders and to have supported, protected and amplified their work at the national, regional and international levels. With them, the "essential workers" of our times, we strive for a 2021 full of freedom, equality, dignity and justice.

Annual Report | Supporting humanity's essential workers

It's difficult to encapsulate such a complex year in a word, but "interconnected" is one that comes to mind when reflecting on 2020. We are proud to have remained deeply interconnected with defenders and to have supported, protected and amplified their work at the national, regional and international levels. With them, the "essential workers" of our times, we strive for a 2021 full of freedom, equality, dignity and justice.

HRC46 | Civil society presents key takeaways from Human Rights Council

16 organisations* share reflections on the key outcomes of the 46th session of the UN Human Rights Council, as well as the missed opportunities to address key issues and situations including pushbacks and other human rights violations faced by migrants and refugees, and the human rights situations in Algeria, Cameroon, China, India, Kashmir and the Philippines. A shortened version was delivered at the Council. Full written version below.

Myanmar | Multinational companies asked to protect civic freedoms and defenders

Civic freedoms, including freedom of expression, association and assembly are essential to stable, profitable and sustainable businesses and investment environments in which companies thrive and economies prosper, writes Andrés Zaragoza, Programme Manager (Business and Human Rights) with ISHR. Multinationals have a role to play in protecting the “shared civic space” in Myanmar.