A view of the flags outside the UN Headquarters during the second day of the general debate of the General Assembly's seventy-fifth session.

Global
News

UNGA81: Third Committee narrowly rejects attempt to erase LGBTIQ victims from resolution on extrajudicial executions

ISHR welcomes the UN General Assembly Third Committee’s adoption of the resolution on extrajudicial, summary or arbitrary executions with its reference to sexual orientation and gender identity intact. But a margin of just five votes is a warning ahead of the plenary vote in December.

On 13 November, the Third Committee adopted the resolution on extrajudicial, summary or arbitrary executions (A/C.3/81/L.37/Rev.1) by 131 votes in favour, none against and 47 abstentions.

The resolution, presented every two years by Finland on behalf of the Nordic countries, reaffirms the obligation of all States to protect the right to life. It calls on them to investigate all unlawful killings promptly, thoroughly and impartially, and to hold those responsible to account. It is slated for confirmation at the General Assembly plenary in December. 

During the adoption, the Committee rejected an amendment (A/C.3/81/L.53) introduced by Egypt on behalf of a group of member States of the Organisation of Islamic Cooperation. The amendment sought to replace the explicit reference to people killed because of their ‘sexual orientation or gender identity’ with ‘any other considerations that make them at heightened risk of extrajudicial, summary or arbitrary executions’.

This amendment was defeated by 74 votes to 69, with 24 abstentions. Two years ago, a similar attempt was defeated by 31 votes (78 to 47) – this year the margin was five. 

The paragraph targeted by the amendment calls on States to investigate killings of people at heightened risk, including killings of persons belonging to national or ethnic, religious and linguistic minorities, Indigenous communities, human rights defenders, lawyers, journalists and demonstrators, as well as killings of persons due to their sexual orientation or gender identity.

The reference to sexual orientation dates from 2002, and to gender identity from 2012. The resolution remains one of the few General Assembly texts to refer explicitly to sexual orientation and gender identity. 

The Committee also rejected two amendments from the Russian Federation, one seeking to delete a reference to the Rome Statute of the International Criminal Court and another seeking to delete an operative paragraph. 

The narrowing margin reflects a shift in the politics of the General Assembly. A similar amendment may be tabled again when the resolution reaches the plenary in December. 

'This was far too close. The Third Committee held the line, but a five-vote margin shows that the right to life of LGBTIQ people is being treated as negotiable. Erasing sexual orientation and gender identity from this resolution would not stop these killings – it would make them easier to ignore. LGBTIQ people, including human rights defenders, are being killed with impunity. In December, States must stand firm: no one should be killed because of who they are or what they do, and every such killing must be investigated.'
Tess McEvoy, ISHR Programme Director.

The evidence for naming sexual orientation and gender identity keeps growing. Outright International’s report Killed for Who They Are records more than 230 targeted killings of LGBTIQ people across all regions since January 2020, and those are only the cases that could be documented. 

On 10 November, ISHR, Amnesty International, Human Rights Watch, ILGA World and Outright International wrote to every UN mission urging them to keep the full list of groups intact, warning that removing any one group would put every other group at risk.

In total, 127 organisations and 2,149 individuals from 112 countries added their names to the call. 

ISHR thanks Finland, Denmark, Iceland, Norway and Sweden for once again presenting the resolution and holding firm on its language, and the States across regions that spoke in its defence, among them Australia, Brazil, Canada, Mexico, Uruguay and the European Union. 

When the resolution comes before the General Assembly plenary in December, ISHR urges all States to vote in favour of it as a whole, and to vote against any amendment that would delete, replace or narrow its list of targeted groups. 

The right to life belongs to everyone. Every State should protect it, without exception. 

Related articles