Photo: Apo-Werken

Chile, Switzerland
, Latin America & Caribbean

Migration | Switzerland should allow Flor Calfunao Paillalef to stay

Human rights defender Flor Calfunao Paillalef can be expelled from Switzerland to Chile at any time, despite the death threats and other abuses affecting her family in Chile. The decision of the State Migration Service undermines Flor's ability to do her work as a human rights defender and calls into question Switzerland's otherwise strong support for the work of defenders.

Since 2011, Flor Calfunao Paillalef has been the UN representative of the Mapuche people, an indigenous people living between Chile and Argentina. In Chile, Flor’s home country which she fled in 1996, the Mapuche are the target of all kinds of abuses by the authorities: arbitrary arrests, unending detentions, judicial harassment – particularly through excessive use of Anti-terrorism laws, looting and even murder.

Those who fight for the defense of the Mapuche people in Chile are frequent targets of this type of abuse. And so are their relatives. Several members of Flor’s family have thus benefited from protection measures by the Inter-American Commission on Human Rights, due to the countless attacks that they have been subjected to because of their activities to defend human rights, their people and their ancestral territory.

Despite successive requests to Switzerland State Migration Service (French acronym SEM) since 2008; despite the recognition Flor’s work for human rights enjoys at the UN; despite the award she received from the City of Geneva in recognition of her commitment to human rights; despite threats to her safety in Chile: Flor has always been denied refugee status by the Swiss authorities. After the Federal Administrative Court took a final decision turning down her case on 11 July 2018, Flor was given until 16 August to leave the country. She therefore decided to ask for a humanitarian permit, a request that is still pending at the time of writing.

What about the threats awaiting Flor in Chile? Has the SEM ignored them or, by any chance, has it not been informed about them? The answer is quite different: the SEM has duly heard about the threats to Flor and the Mapuche people, but, the SEM says, these threats would only occur in Auracania, the home region of the Mapuche. All Flor would have to do then would be to settle in another region. Away from her relatives. And away from any means to continue her work for human rights and the rights of her people. This perspective is both unacceptable and contrary to Switzerland’s international commitments to human rights defenders.

Indeed, according to the UN Declaration on Human Rights Defenders, the primary obligation to protect human rights and those who defend them lies with States (article 2). Protecting defenders includes the adoption of “legislative, administrative and other measures necessary to ensure the effective guarantee of the rights and freedoms referred to in the (…) Declaration.” (Ibid.) A decision by Swiss authorities which would lead to endangering a human rights defender and putting a halt to their work is far from achieving this goal.

From Geneva, Flor is able to attend the Human Rights Council, where she is the only person bringing the concerns of her people to the agenda. If she is returned to Chile, the Mapuche people will have lost their voice at the UN. As a host country for the Council and the Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights, Switzerland needs to be more consistent and be equally welcoming to those who actually defend human rights. Switzerland must review its decision to expel Flor. If not, this would be a blow to the Swiss State’s international credibility, which would be held accountable to the international community for endangering a human rights defender.


Related articles

ACHPR 69: the situation of human rights defenders in exile in Africa

Concerned about the increase in the number of human rights defenders in exile in Africa, during its 27th Extraordinary session, the African Commission on Human and Peoples’ Rights (‘the African Commission’) adopted resolution 439 mandating the African Commission to publish a report on the Situation of Human Rights Defenders in Exile in Africa.

Elections | Human Rights Council Pledging Event 2021

This week in an online event, 10 candidate States publicly spoke to an audience of around 200 people on their pledges as incoming Human Rights Council members for 2022 – 2024. They also faced questions on pressing human rights issues from both States and civil society organisations.

Annual Report | Supporting humanity's essential workers

It's difficult to encapsulate such a complex year in a word, but "interconnected" is one that comes to mind when reflecting on 2020. We are proud to have remained deeply interconnected with defenders and to have supported, protected and amplified their work at the national, regional and international levels. With them, the "essential workers" of our times, we strive for a 2021 full of freedom, equality, dignity and justice.

HRC46 | Civil society presents key takeaways from Human Rights Council

16 organisations* share reflections on the key outcomes of the 46th session of the UN Human Rights Council, as well as the missed opportunities to address key issues and situations including pushbacks and other human rights violations faced by migrants and refugees, and the human rights situations in Algeria, Cameroon, China, India, Kashmir and the Philippines. A shortened version was delivered at the Council. Full written version below.

HRC2021 | Blueprint for States to ensure that the Human Rights Council continues to be credible, accessible and effective

For many rights holders, victims and activists, the UN Human Rights Council provides the last or only opportunity to get international attention and support for their vital work towards a world that’s more fair, equal and sustainable. We need the Council to continue being credible, effective and accessible to everyone. This is only possible if States demonstrate leadership, take principled action, ensure that Council members live up to their responsibilities and expectations, and fully cooperate with the Council’s mechanisms.

HRC45 | Criminalisation of defenders in Europe must end

The dire situation of refugees and other migrants in Greece, and elsewhere across the Mediterranean, deserves the Human Rights Council’s attention. NGOs pressed European governments today on the incompatibility between protecting defenders abroad, and criminalising them at home.

HRC45 | Key issues on the agenda of September 2020 session

The Human Rights Council's 45th session will take place from 14 September to 6 October 2020. The Council will consider issues including reprisals, rights of indigenous peoples and people of African descent, arbitrary detention, and enforced disappearances, among others. It will present an opportunity to address grave human rights situations in States including Yemen, China, the United States of America, Saudi Arabia, Libya, the Philippines, Venezuela, Burundi and Myanmar, among many others. Here’s an overview of some of the key issues on the agenda.

NGO Forum | Panel on the impact of Covid-19 on the 2020 African Union’s theme: “Silencing the Guns in Africa” & the 20th anniversary of the UNSCR 1325

Version française ici

Covid-19 took the whole world by surprise. Considered a health crisis at the beginning, it turned into an economic and social crisis with a general impact on the fundamental human rights and particularly on women's human rights. Women living in crisis areas are particularly affected and at risk.

ACHPR65 | Outcome of the 65th session of the African Commission

The African Commission on Human and Peoples’ Rights (the African Commission) held its 65th ordinary session from 21 October to 10 November 2019 in Banjul, Republic of The Gambia. This session focused on the African Union theme: 'Refugees, Returnees and Internally Displaced Persons: Towards Sustainable Solutions to Forced Displacement in Africa.'

Supporting Defenders | Building skills & solidarity – Human Rights Defender Advocacy Programme 2019

Over two intense weeks, 18 dedicated human rights defenders participating in ISHR’s 2019 Human Rights Defenders Advocacy Programme (HRDAP) exchanged experiences, strengthened their skills, put them into practice, and built a network of allies in Geneva and across the globe.