Photo: CC0


Treaty Bodies | Backlog in individual complaints must be addressed now

Everyone should have equal access to justice, as stated in the Universal Declaration of Human Rights and the UN Sustainable Development Goals. A group of over 40 organisations and individual have called on the UN High Commissioner for Human Rights to urgently address the massive backlog and delays in processing individual complaints to the UN treaty bodies.

When Jeehan Mahmood and Ahmed Tholal submitted a report to the Universal Periodic Review of the Maldives in September 2014, they were simply doing their jobs as Commissioners of the Human Rights Commission of the Maldives (HRCM). The report focused on prominent human rights issues faced by defenders in the Maldives, including access to justice. It questioned the functioning of the judiciary on grounds of independence, transparency, interference, influence, competency, consistency, and accessibility.

The Supreme Court of the Maldives retaliated and prosecuted the HRCM arguing that the report was unlawful, biased and undermined judicial independence, and ordered the HRCM to follow a set of guidelines designed to restrict the HRCM’s work and its ability to communicate with the UN.

In September 2016, Jeehan Mahmood and Ahmed Tholal took their case to the UN Human Rights Committee with ISHR’s support, seeking recognition of the right to submit information to UN human rights mechanisms. Yet two years after submitting their complaint, they had yet to receive confirmation that their case had even been registered by the OHCHR, which receives and handles complaints to the UN treaty bodies.

Unfortunately, this is not an isolated situation. In the current context, it would take more than four years to deal with the current backlog of 977 communications pending review, excluding new communications received during the same period. The OHCHR unit dealing with complaints receives more than 20’000 pieces of correspondence on a monthly basis, and yet have less than 20 lawyers on staff working to register the complaints. It is clearly an impossible task.

This unacceptable situation prompted ISHR and TRIAL International to initiate an open letter to High Commissioner Bachelet, asking her to address the current inability of her office to deal effectively with the volume of complaints submitted to treaty bodies.

“The delays in obtaining even a registration of an individual complaint to a treaty body are unacceptable,” said ISHR’s legal counsel Madeleine Sinclair. “We know that it takes several years for a decision to be made once a case is registered, but victims cannot wait, and justice is being severely undermined,” she added.

“We understand the High Commissioner is taking the problem seriously,” said ISHR’s head of treaty body advocacy Vincent Ploton. “States have been asked to provide resources for additional staff to the OHCHR unit that receives complaints, but so far only Japan and Hungary have positively responded. Both OHCHR and States need to urgently review budgetary allocations so as to enable the treaty bodies to decide cases in a timely manner” he concluded.



Related articles

Elections of the Human Rights Council President for the 18th cycle in 2024

On 8 December 2023, the UN Human Rights Council (the Council) announced that a vote is expected in January 2024, possibly on 10 January 2024, to elect the Council’s President for the 18th cycle in 2024 from the Africa Group. The State representatives who have put forward their candidacies are Morocco and South Africa. In a joint letter, NGOs urge all members of the Council to elect the Council President based on Council membership criteria.

Stay in the loop!

Would you like to be informed of future events, news, updates on our work, invitations and appeals? Please enter your email address below!